
MG/YA Book Reviews by a MG/YA Author
Table of Contents
Author News
MG/YA Book Reviews
In the Garden
Author News
Welcome to the February edition of Bookcase Bizarro!
First up in today’s author news: book blurbs.
Love ’em or hate ’em, if you’re a writer you’ve eventually got to roll up your sleeves and tackle the dreaded task.
In January, I rolled up my proverbial sleeves and got to work on juicing up the book blurb I wrote for Rogue Wizard, which I first posted here. It needed work. Although I’ve become a better blurb writer by writing my own descriptions for the books I review for this blog, I still struggle with writing my own blurbs. So I wondered what a combination of human and AI feedback would yield?
First, I posted the blurb on Reddit (r/selfpublish) in search of some skilled writerly feedback. Reddit did not disappoint. One writer who commented gave me very direct and honest feedback about what was not working, which was super useful. (My query also generated almost a thousand views and drove traffic to my website, which was an extra bonus.)
Here’s the blurb after a rewrite:
Colin, an illegal wizard at the St. Anselm’s Training School for Orphans, has a big problem. The Magistrates, the relentless wizard hunters of 1828 Garrison Creek, have stepped up their patrols. It’s only a matter of time before Colin’s discovered, drained of all his powers and cast out of the Creek. He needs a cover, fast.
Lucky for him, a solution is close at hand: an elite squad of magical technology students whose actions are rarely questioned. It’s the last place the Magistrates will look for a wizard.
To get in, Colin will need to compete against the best. Only, he’s not so great at magi-tech spells. His wizard’s conjurements are explosive and instantaneous, but they’re difficult to control. Worse, they leave behind a telltale red wizard’s residue the Magistrates can track.With his arch rival, Viola Grundy, also vying for top spot, time is running out.
When Colin impulsively unleashes his wizard’s power in an illegal duel with Viola, the Magistrates are summoned to the school to test both students for signs of wizardry. Unable to use his powers to save himself, Colin must find a way to outsmart his rival and the authorities, or pay an unthinkable price.
Better, but it still needed work. So I ran it through Google Gemini with the following prompt:
You are the head of marketing in the children’s book division of a Big 5 publishing company with an expertise in writing book blurbs. Please improve the following blurb: [INSERT BLURB]
To my surprise, the AI provided three different options: a punchy and commercial high-stakes option; an atmospheric option that emphasized character and voice; and a short and snappy option. I asked Gemini to combine the first two options to create a new blurb, which it did. None of the options generated by Gemini worked well on their own, and the overwrought language it used often sounded like a bad Hollywood movie trailer: One illegal wizard. One relentless rival. Zero room for error. However, it certainly gave me plenty of ideas to work with and provided me with a solid framework to anchor the blurb. I could clearly see how I could use the examples AI provided to shape my own paragraphs. After one final revision from my exacting editor, Dawn Loewen, this is what I ended up with:
As an illegal wizard at St. Anselm’s Training School for Orphans, Colin lives in constant fear of the Magistrates—the relentless wizard hunters scouring Garrison Creek for people like him. He needs a place to hide, and fast.
The school’s elite magi-tech squad offers the perfect camouflage.
But the competition is fierce and Colin’s magi-tech skills are … not great. Worse, he can’t always control his wizardry, and it leaves behind a telltale red residue that acts as a beacon for the authorities. With his arch rival, Viola Grundy, also vying for a spot on the squad, time is running out.
When a heated battle with Viola forces Colin to unleash his explosive wizard powers, the Magistrates come to inspect both students for signs of wizardry. Trapped between a rival who knows too much and the hunters who suspect him, Colin must rely on his wits alone to outsmart them all—or risk being drained of his powers and cast out of the Creek forever.
165 words compared to the nearly 250-word blurb I wrote for Shadow Apprentice. That’s what I call an improvement!
For me, there were few important caveats to using AI, even for book marketing: I wrote the first draft of the blurb myself, with no input from Gemini. I re-wrote the blurb to incorporate the human feedback I received from Reddit. Only then did I feed it into Gemini. I didn’t have a problem with this, since a blurb is marketing copy and is meant to be widely distributed. I don’t feed any of my books into an LLM, and I don’t use AI to write any of my fiction. (NOTE: This is a personal choice and not meant as a prescriptive manifesto for anyone else.) Finally, I turned the blurb over to a professional editor for a last pass. To my mind, AI is not good enough to write a convincing blurb, but it can be a decent assistant to a skilled writer who knows which suggestions to adapt and which ones to discard. If you ask me, that’s a pretty compelling reason for a writer to prioritize their writing skills and craft over going all in on AI.
In way more exciting news, Rogue Wizard: a Garrison Creek Prequel Novella is edited, formatted, and nearly ready to go. I’m currently finalizing my book cover with designer Jessica Bell. All current subscribers will be emailed a free ebook of Rogue Wizard before it goes on sale or gets used as a reader magnet for new subscribers.
This month, we accompany a runaway who must choose between exploring her indigenous roots or fleeing from a past that may literally kill her. If you’re a fan of Indigenous Noir (or even if you’ve never heard of it), read on!
A quick note to new readers: books that are available from the Toronto Public Library will be marked #TPL, because books don’t have to be new or owned in order to be loved.
MG/YA Book Reviews

Lucy Smith lost the only home she ever knew when her father died. In the five years she’s spent in and out of foster care, any sense of “home” has disappeared and belonging, when she finds it, is fleeting. When her current placement becomes dangerous, she decides she’s done with foster care. A life on the run is better than remaining a ward of the state.
But all of Lucy’s careful planning and disguises go awry when Mr. Jameson and his friend, Daunis, come searching for her with the news that she is Ojibwe, and has a family and a home on Sugar Island, Michigan, if she wants it.
Lucy wants to believe them, but how does she know they are telling the truth? And will this new family still want her when they discover more about her and the things she’s done? And how will she keep them safe once the past catches up to her, as it always does?
Angeline Boulley says that Sisters of the Wind was her most “… intense, heart-wrenching and difficult writing experience.”
It’s also her most emotionally raw work.
Lucy Smith is surrounded by adults who do not have her best interests at heart, and the people she loves the most are sometimes critically flawed. Her beloved father chooses not to notice how coldly his new wife treats Lucy in his almost desperate eagerness to experience happiness in his second marriage. He can’t overcome the pain of being left by Lucy’s mother, so he lies to Lucy about her indigenous heritage for fear that Lucy’s questions might rip open unhealed scars. There’s no question that he loves Lucy, but he often confuses love with self-protection.
Lucy’s stepmother, Bridget, is a religious zealot and also reveals herself to be manipulative and controlling. Lucy wonders how her father could remain in a marriage that’s so obviously loveless, without realizing that he’s chosen not to see it. She decides to try to be the best stepdaughter she can, hoping to stabilize things for her father. But nothing can change Bridget. After Lucy’s father dies, Lucy realizes she’s not safe with Bridget and sets out on her own. But not without aiming a last strike against Bridget where it will hurt the most.
Foster care is a mixed bag for Lucy, mostly bad. The most outwardly moral foster homes are also the most toxic. Boulley uses this to illustrate how systemic corruption plays out, and also to show exactly what foster kids—especially Indigenous kids—are up against. Lucy meets each challenge with a tough resilience that has its roots in her father’s love and in the one good foster home she lived in. She also enacts her own version of justice upon her tormentors in small and big ways, knowing that they will otherwise never be held accountable.
One of Boulley’s great strengths as a writer lies in her ability to craft a unique main character with every new book. Each one of her protagonists has a specific voice and perspective. Lucy offers a new take on Daunis, the hero of Boulley’s first novel, Firekeeper’s Daughter, who pops up as a secondary character. Through Lucy’s eyes, we observe new flaws and blind spots in Daunis that we didn’t see before, and we know things about Daunis that Lucy doesn’t. It’s a more complex version of the reader knowing things that are hidden from the main character. While each of Boulley’s novels functions as a standalone, reading them together deepens our sense of the Sugar Island community precisely because the characters overlap between them.
Unlike the open-hearted Daunis, Lucy is a closed book, even to herself. She doesn’t take readers into her confidence right away. Instead, she reveals her story slowly over the course of the novel, until the past intrudes with such urgency that it burns its way into the present. The only question is whether readers will jump to conclusions about Lucy, like everyone else, or let her reveal herself in her own way? And what if Lucy’s got parts of her own story wrong?
Another of Boulley’s strengths is the powerful sense of agency and self-determination her female characters possess. It’s a fierce essence that blazes through each one of their stories. They don’t see themselves as victims even when they’re being victimized. Like Daunis and Perry before her, Lucy uproots and fights against systemic injustice by solving the mystery at the heart of the novel. This mystery is the most chilling and harrowing one yet. With the help of a strong community and culture, Lucy, like Daunis and Perry, finds a place to call home, even if her friends sometimes don’t.
It’s hard to discuss the ending of a book without giving anything away, so I’ll just say that changing the POV for one chapter did not work for me as a reader, but I understand why Boulley did it.
In an author’s note, Boulley labels the attacks on the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) in the U.S. as an attempt to dissolve tribal sovereignty in order to control access to critical minerals. If ICWA is all about the children, the attacks on ICWA have nothing to do with the children. Sisters in the Wind is a perfect companion text for social studies teachers. I realize that American teachers at this political juncture may find this problematic, but there’s nothing to stop Canadian teachers from exploring these connections.
Recommended for teachers and for YA readers who can take an edgy mystery with a genuinely creepy true crime angle. (#TPL)
In the Garden
Well, I managed to kill off ALL my spinach seedlings with over-watering. Despite the 30+ years of gardening under my belt, the art/science of watering continues to elude me. (Sigh.)
Never mind. There are extra lettuce seedlings ready to be transplanted into the space. The sprouts are still going gangbusters (we’re eating them in smoothies every morning). Spider mites have invaded the Peppermint Swiss chard, but the plants are still growing nicely. I’ve been spraying them with water to discourage the mites, but they are very tenacious. I think it’s time to up the game with some homemade insecticidal soap. Interestingly, the nearby Ruby Red chard is completely unaffected.
The most exciting news is that my adorable Black Dragon coleus plants emerged and are growing well. Fortunately, my wonky watering hasn’t killed them off. (Keep your fingers crossed.)






From L-R, T-B
Black Dragon coleus, oak leaf lettuce and coral plant, Peppermint Swiss chard, Simpson Elite lettuce, Spicy Globe basil flowers, Lolla Rossa lettuce.


Thirteen-year-old Ermin is a gifted mechanic and the worst student at St. Anselm’s Training School for Orphans. She’s just failed her exams for the third time—something nobody’s ever done. Worse, Ermin’s been running her own repair business for money—something that’s expressly forbidden. If the headmistress finds out, Ermin will go to prison. Her future will be over before it’s even begun.
But that’s not her only secret.
Her best friends, Colin and Georgie, are wizards in a world where magic is strictly controlled. Ermin worries that her friends will be captured, drained of their power, then banished. When Georgie’s caught aiding the Wizard’s Resistance, Ermin repairs a broken flying carpet so all three of them can escape.
Hesitant to join the Resistance because of her lack of magical power, Ermin steals an experimental device from a wizard hunter that could destroy every wizard in the Creek. She’s faced with a choice: either smash the device or convert it into a different kind of weapon—one that not only helps wizards but just might get her an apprenticeship at the prestigious Guild Academy.
Ermin’s got one chance to get it right. If she fails, she risks losing her two best friends… and her dreams.
Find Shadow Apprentice at your local library, bookstore, or favourite online retailer.
Thanks for being a Bookcase Bizarro reader! I’ll be back next month with more author news, and more MG and YA book reviews. See you then!

#IMWAYR is a weekly blog hop hosted by Unleashing Readers and Teach Mentor Texts. Its focus is to share the love of KIDLIT and recommend KIDLIT books to readers of all ages.
Greg Pattridge also hosts weekly MG blog hop MMGM every Monday at his website, Always in the Middle.

Interesting journey with writing, AI and back to writing. I’m impressed with your perseverance! Sisters in the Wind sounds like an amazing book. Happy MMGM!
Thanks, Carol! It sounds like a lot of work, but it ended up taking much less time than my usual book blurb writing efforts. All of Angeline Boulley’s books are good. I’d recommend starting with Firekeeper’s Daughter (if you haven’t already read it).
I learned much from your column today. Now I’m intrigued by all the titles you shared today. I love that your newest book stars another character from your first book. So Many Books, so Little Time!. I usually gravitate to MG mysteries, but any conflict produces mysterious plots, so my TBR list grows!
I agree with your assessment of Angeline Bouilley’s books. MMGM is giving me inspiration today and I’ve only read 2 articles this morning 🌄. Thank you!
Thank you, Beth! It’s true that Boulley is YA rather than MG, but her mysteries are so unique, as you know. What are some of your MG favourites? Inquiring minds want to know.
It was great fun to tell a Garrison Creek story from a different character’s POV. I hope that people will enjoy reading it as much as I enjoyed writing it.
I liked both the blurbs. Congrats on being almost ready to publish your manuscript. I really enjoyed Firekeeper’s Daughter. Sisters in the Winds sounds like another one I’ll enjoy from your review. Thanks.
I think you would like it, Natalie. It’s good to get your feedback on both book blurbs. I liked both too, but these days, the shorter the better. I don’t think that’s always a good thing. I like a blurb that gives me some idea of the character, their goals and the stakes instead of a bunch of vaguely worded tropes, like some of the super short ones do. It was hard to strike the right balance, for sure.
It was really interesting hearing how you revised your blurb. And using the feedback on Reddit is such a great idea! I also love your beautiful plants!
Thanks, Jenni! I love that you love the plants. (And they love it, too.)
Reddit is certainly not for the faint of heart, and it took me a while before I developed a thick enough skin to handle the blunt tone there. It helps that I’m not emotionally invested in my book blurbs. I don’t know that I would ask Redditors for feedback on my novels!
So much good information in this post. Braving Reddit is, well, very brave of you. Thanks for the post.
Thanks, Rosi. Yes, braving Reddit is about right. It’s not for the faint of heart.